Joe Raedle | Getty Images
Chipotle restaurant workers fill orders for customers on April 27, 2015 in Miami.
Restaurants that take advantage of add-on menus, or low-priced items that diners can order as part of a larger meal, have been most successful, the analyst said.
“You still have a low base price, but people come in and buy other things as well,” Hottovy said.
Still, Morningstar placed a hold rating on both Chipotle and Darden and said the companies could benefit from better workforce training, new products and improved order of operations.
“There’s a lot of excitement that comes from [stocks surging], but you have to balance that with … some tempered margin expectations,” Hottovy said.